Our latest news

A Love for Our Downtown – Fayetteville Square

Bagley & Bagley Insurance is an agency who cares deeply about its roots. Opening in 1907 we have over 107 years of traditions that include some of our local traditions in Fayetteville and Lincoln County. We have been located on the Fayetteville Square since our origination in 1907. Both our exisiting location at 102 College Street East Fayetteville, TN and old location in the Pythian Building or locally known as the “KP” Building or the “Knights of Pythian Buildings” are featured in this video from JMcNeal Services and Fayetteville Main Street including local performers Daniel Harry and Jerry Taylor. We appreciate others who take pride in our downtown and in “preserving its past and preparing for its future”.

A Man’s Worth

Bagley & Bagley believes a man’s worth can be measured by his work, not his words, so they continue to strive to meet their customer’s needs and expectations. Part of meeting those needs is meeting the needs of their community. Lincoln County is close to their hearts and they make arrangements to be involved in community activities whenever possible. Cary has been involved in the community in many different ways including being past President of the Lincoln County Chapter of the American Cancer Society and as coordinator for over 20 Lucy Carter Williams - Local Artistyears of Lincoln County’s Fabulous Fifties Show, a musical montage and a major fund raiser for cancer victims. David serves as a board member of the First National Bank and was a former member and president of the Rotary Club. Battle Bagley was away for several years pursuing a career as a CPA, but his love for Fayetteville brought him back home over 20 years ago to Bagley & Bagley. He continually seeks educational opportunities in the insurance field to better himself for his customers. He recently completed a course giving him the title of Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC).

The Bagley family has deep roots in Lincoln County and they want you to know your insurance needs are their top priority. With four generations of service the stability of this agency speaks for itself and they expect the same from the insurance companies they represent. Bagley & Bagley Insurance is lincensed in Tennessee and Alabama.